Skip to main content

Concept of Sin in Hinduism

What exactly is sin? How do you define sin? What all acts comprise sin? Every religion in the world has developed a set of rules that tell us what is good and what is sin. Then they ask you stay away from sin so that you don't end up in hell after your life on the planet ends. When you deviate from those rules, you are supposedly committing a sin. Does anything like sin really exist?

The concept of SIN has always been a debatable topic in Hinduism (let's see it separate for a while, from the Sanathan Dharma being practiced as Hindu religion). I am not saying sin doesn't exist. I have my own reservations that I present in this post. As always, the topic - SIN in HINDUISM - is open to debate and you can debate it here in comments or via email link below the post.

In the formative years of Bharatvarsha (India), when the learned wanted to bring in a peaceful social structure in place, they brought in the concept of sin. There is no exact definition of sin but if you listen to Mahatma Gandhi, sin is an act that makes you feel guilt.  But then, if you feel guilt after eating a pizza, did you sin? Some people feel guilty after sex act. Are they sinners? Isn't it a natural process required to keep the species alive? One might bring in the scenario of adultery into this so I will say a line about it as well... later, below.

Before that, I should say - before Indus valley civilization was actually civilized- the nomads and cavemen committed way too many sins, if you go by the current religious books. When I say 'current religious books', I mean the distorted versions of original books written by the learned. Often, things are lost in translation ...but in almost all religions, this distortion is deliberate have a better command over people and their acts (as well as thoughts).

You probably know most governments are controlled by the Vatican. You might also have seen Muslim uprising as a direct result of US' greed for oil. Not to mention the Hindus who are hell scared that they are going extinct. Where do these theories fit in? As long as people believe they are sinners, they carry a broken image of theirs with them everywhere. To get help, they'll go to priests and godmen who take advantage of their guilt. It is easy to control a broken person as he or she would be listening and adhering to it pretty sincerely.

One particular religion advocates that people are born sinners. That the sins of their ancestors is their own sin. Once they start believing it, they look for redemption. The power centers utilize this weakness of common people without any mercy. They have books, for example, the Garuda Purana which is supposedly written by Lord Vishnu to explain the types of punishments one has to undergo for each sin mentioned there. The punishments are in place to tame people so that the social balance always remains there... in the favor of religious gurus who work for governments directly or indirectly, in implementing its decisions. But they also help in containing crime and things like that because there is a punishment already there, waiting to catch them as soon as they commit a supposed sinister act.

Coming back to ancient India, various acts that prevented peace and harmony among people and other inhabitants of the planet, were first identified and then categorized as sin. This was done so that people do not go about killing and harming other people or animals. That doesn't mean if you are a butcher, you are incurring sin on a daily basis. You are just following your dharma, which in this case, is to sell animal meat. In some cultures, the thought of hurting cow is a sin. This came into place because the ancient sages want to preserve cows because of the different benefits one avails from these animals. Actually, cow is considered holy in Hinduism as well as Sanathan Dharma.

So? Don't hurt cows. It is a sin. It will give you bad if you sell the cow for its meat. The topic is under debate... many states in India have banned cow meat and yet India is one of the largest exporters of cow meat. I do not know where the balance hangs in this case. Are they the governments sinning or are they the people into meat export. I'll leave this example here at this so you may deduce on your own about the sin incurred, whether it is a sin and also, who is the sinner in this case.

Taking up the issue of adultery, it is defined as  infidelity of a partner in a relationship towards the other partner. The concept of sin here in Hinduism is to keep both partners faithful towards each other so that they and their offspring live in peace. In such cases, if one commits adultery, it certainly is considered a almost all religions. But then again, some cultures allow polygamy. For example, if a religious book says a man can have four wives, then he is sleeping with four wives and it it okay with God. If the female sleeps with someone else, it is a grave sin... whose punishment is, in most cases, death or at least ouster from mainstream society.

Mahabharata cites Draupadi has five husbands. So according to religion A, it is a sin and according to religion B, it is not a sin. There are many a folklore here and I guess I am not the right person to comment on that so I leave out this example too, again, so you may deduce the sin and sinner. I must add that while Draupadi had five husbands, each of the husband except perhaps Nakula, had more than one wives. But Mahabharata is again a saga that may or may not be just a myth. It doesn't make much difference though. Sin is sin and if you bathe in river Ganges after committing sin, all your sins go *pooof* (vanish/forgiven).

The idea of sin is to tame people who will otherwise be barbaric like demons. With fear of God instilled in their brains, they prevent incidents (sins) that often create chaos. With that in mind, the learned of yester ages created the concept of sin. The acts of sin and the extent of punishment vary in different religions. Also, what is sin in some religion may be perfectly okay in some other religion.

I read a comment somewhere on a YouTube video. I am reproducing it here as it adds to the above argument...Here it goes:
"Rightness" or "Wrongness" is not an intrinsic condition. It is a subjective judgement in a personal value system. A thing is only right or wrong because you say it is. A thing is not right or wrong intrinsically. The first thing to understand about the universe is that no condition is "good" or "bad". You cannot know and become that which you are, in the absence of that which you are not. What would happen if everything I thought was "wrong" was actually right"? Evil is that which you call Evil. Yet even that I love; for it is only through that which you call evil that you know good". ~ Vinod P.

With that, I conclude my argument about SIN in Hinduism. Please comment your views. I am more than willing to know what people think about this.

Problem with the above post? Send us an email

Popular on Powercut Media

Best app for Android phones - Clean Master from Cheetah Mobile

After five years of testing different multipurpose apps for Android maintenance, I realize Clean Master from Cheetah Mobile is the best maintenance app for Android phones. Not only maintenance, Clean Master offers you much more than you can expect from a single app. For a while, it felt the "All in One for Android" is good. But turned out it leaves out add-ins even after you remove it. What is available in single code in Clean Master of Cheetah Mobile, is available as add-ins in All in One app for Android. When you uninstall All in One app, the add-ins continue to run in RAM. I could not find any method to remove them as they were not visible in any App Managers. I had to do a factory reset and that was when my doubts were removed and I acknowledged Clean Master of Cheetah Mobile is the best option for Android phones. Lock Screen Here are features at a glance. Let's start from Lock Screen. Replacing your phone lock screen, you can set up Clean Master Lock Scr

Significance or Meaning of Swaha and Ithi in Sanskrit Mantras

You might have noticed that all mantras begin with the sound of "OM". What you might have ignored or failed to notice that mantras in Sanskrit end with "ithi" or "swaha". Some of you end mantras with just a "namah". Not to scare you, but if you fail to use "ithi" at end of each mantra or at the very end of any stotra (hymn), the mantra & related offering (sacrifice or prasadam) doesn't reach the god being prayed. The word "ithi" marks the end of mantra, and urges gods to accept whatever you are offering. The word "swaha" is used more in havans (rituals were you put offerings/prasad directly into fire). Since people put offerings into fire while saying "swaha", many of us associate it with "destruction". When anyone says "sab kuch swaha ho gaya (everything became swaha)", it does and should not be concluded that he or she lost things. It is a wrong notion that associates &qu

Analysis of Mahabharata Characters - Bhishma

Bhishma is one of the powerful characters of the epic, Mahabharata that contains and shows a pious way of life to the mortals living on earth. I am starting this Analysis of Mahabharata Characters with Bhishma as he is the oldest character in the epic/saga and has tremendous influence on the other characters of Mahabharata. Bhishma was the son of king Shantanu and Ganga (the river Ganges in female form). Bhishma was considered one of the eight Vasus (rishis) who had to take birth on earth due to a curse. Before we analyze the character, let us take a quick look at the story of Bhishma according to the Mahabharata. Background Of Bhishma Bhismha is considered one of the eight Vasus who stole a cow named Kamadhenu from a sage. When the sage cursed them to take birth as humans, all Vasus asked for his forgiveness. The sage, for seven Vasus who helped the main Vasu to steal the cow, reduced the curse to death just after birth. However, the main Vasu who actually stole the cow was